Dear Mr Guy Garvey
You are brilliant. Your Northern dulcet tones put everything I’ve ever wanted to say about anything into words. Lovely, beautiful words that your inarticulate devotees are only too grateful for – because when we lowly dregs try to express emotion only clunky clichés come jumbling out. Your lyrics have filled more of my birthday cards, letters and phone calls than you could possibly imagine. I also like your beard.
The awards and recognition that you have recently received are long over-due and it’s only right that the general public have finally recognised your brilliance. But, as a fan since the near-beginning, I couldn’t help getting misty eyed when I came to see you play at Wembley on last Saturday.
As always, you were all on top form – the atmosphere was electric and the set-list was a veritable chocolate-box full of treats for fans old and new. But I was left with the same sinking feeling my sister must have felt all those years ago when she played me Newborn for the first time… I wish “other people” didn’t like you too.
For years you were my best kept secret, only to be shared with a select like-minded few. It was like fancying the slightly nerdy kid at school – until one of those crappy cool kids decided that he actually was a bit of all right and sunk her plastic nails into him faster than you could say ‘geek chic’. Yes, yes – I know this is selfish and loving your music should be like reading a good book (you want to share it with the world) but in reality, I kinda, sorta wish that you’d stay so niche and commercially unpopular that you were destined to spend your gig-playing days singing in venues so small you could name-check every member of the audience.
The first time I saw Elbow it felt like a revelation. Before I never realised what an all-encompassing experience a gig should be… the banter you had with the audience, the band’s natural sense of humour and most importantly the sheer beauty of your songs left me feeling like I’d heard live music for the first, proper, time.
And from that moment I was hooked. I started to see life through your lyrics – with every album, every song feeling like it was mirroring every situation I was going through. Switching Off played through my mind when I lay in bed with my boyfriend… and later Red made me realise the relationship was going nowhere… Puncture Repair was a gift to a friend who had always been there for me… and I blasted Station Approach through my dinky iPod headphones when I left London to come back and live at home.
So, naturally, I couldn’t wait for Seldom Seen Kid and more importantly the tour that went with it. I booked my tickets and in April 2008 me, my sister and best buddy were set to see you at Brixton. All that was left for us to do was wait and be wowed. I remember the first time I heard Grounds for Divorce. I was aimlessly flicking through the music channels one Sunday morning when the video caught my eye. “Monday’s is for drinking to the Seldom Seen Kid…”I was already in love. As you banged the tankard down on the bar it was like you were announcing “we’re back!”
Fresh out the studio and still at the start of the tour – the performance you gave at Brixton was phenomenal. Even when you stumbled over the words to Newborn you modestly laughed it off and started from the beginning – which we all adored, as it meant we got to hear our favourite tune twice in one gig,
Following my inevitable post-gig blues I made sure I knew when you were next back in town – 14th March 2009; almost one year on. But what followed during those twelve months was a mixture of highs and lows... elated that you got what you finally deserved, and nostalgic for the days when no-one knew who you were. At the end of the Wembley gig, as confetti filled the arena and the crowd chanted 'one day like this a year would see me right', you threw on your suit jacket and hugged your best friends. It felt like the end of a long journey for you and your fans and the beginning of a whole new one.
Now Mr Garvey – you’re never going to read this letter. Not because I’m accusing you of ‘selling out’ or getting ‘too big’… only that I’m never actually going to send this letter to you. All this is, is one fan's version of a childhood strop. Angry and sad that somebody else wants to play with her favourite toy. All I hope is that you don't forget us, the one's who didn't care if you had a Brit or a Mercury award. Please keep making songs that will become the soundtrack to our lives and don't worry about tailoring your songs to the masses. 'Cos in the words of Whitney we 'will always love you'.
Love you, Mate
Jenni Day



